Vintage Gold Jewelry: Gold vs Gold Filled vs Gold Plated

Vintage Gold Jewelry

About Vintage Gold Jewelry

In a previous article I discussed silver jewelry hallmarks – you can read that article here: Silver Jewelry Marks: Learn to Identify and Date Silver Jewelry. I recently came across a piece of jewelry that had a gold filled mark, but was silver in color. It turns out the piece was gold filled white gold. While researching, I discovered that many people are a bit confused by all of the terms used to describe gold content, especially when dealing with vintage gold jewelry, so this article will shed some light and sort things out.

There are several ways gold is used to produce jewelry. These include gold plated, gold filled and rolled gold, and karat gold. The chart below explains these processes

Vintage Gold Jewelry Processes
Gold processes used to create vintage gold jewelry

Gold Plated Vintage Jewelry

Most of the vintage gold jewelry that you’ll see is gold plated. It’s created by bonding a very fine layer of gold to a base metal using an electromagnetic process. The gold layer is only a few microns thick, so the plating will wear off in time. Typically the gold plating is 18K or 22K (see the Karat Gold Vintage Jewelry section below for an explanation of these markings). The process involves dipping a base metal, such as steel or brass, into an electroplating solution with a lump of solid gold. An electric current is applied, which deposits a very thin layer of gold on the metal.

Vintage Cocktail Ring marked as Heavy Gold Electroplate (HGE), plated with 18 Karat Gold
Vintage Cocktail Ring marked as Heavy Gold Electroplate (H.G.E), plated with 18 Karat Gold

The layer of gold in gold plated jewelry is normally a tiny fraction (about one 1,000 to one 1,000,000) of an inch thick. Heavy gold electroplate might be two or three 1,000s of an inch thick (also known as 2 or 3 mils). Gold plated jewelry may or may not contain a purity mark; most gold plated pieces do not.

Gold Vermeil Vintage Jewelry

Gold Vermeil refers to silver jewelery which is coated with karat gold, also known as “gilded silver.” The silver is usually Sterling, which is 92.5% silver, and can sometimes be higher. Using a process called “electrolysis” the silver is treated with electricity and an acid bath, which attaches the gold to sterling. The gold is commonly 18K or higher, although a minimum of 10K may be used to consider the piece Vermeil. According to the U.S. FTC (Federal Trade Commission), Vermeil should have a minimum gold thickness of 2.5 microns (or 1/100,000 inch) on all surfaces. Typically, the thickness is somewhere between gold plated and gold filled jewelry.

Because Vermeil jewelry is made with only precious metals, it is more valuable. In addition, the layer of gold is thicker than plated metals and will keep its color much longer. It’s not unusual for vintage Vermeil pieces that are 20-50 years old to still have a lovely bright color. Some Vermeil pieces have a rose gold finish and some may have both rose and yellow gold to create a “tri-color gold” look. Although Vermeil can tarnish, a gentle buff with a specially treated silver polishing cloth will usually brighten it right up.

Sterling Yellow Gold Vermeil Blue Glass Stones Flower
1940s Yellow Gold Vermeil Blue Glass Flower Brooch
Coro Sterling Vermeil Moth Brooch
Coro Sterling Rose Gold Vermeil Moth Brooch
Reja Sterling Vermeil Giraffe
1940s Reja Sterling Rose Gold Vermeil Giraffe Brooch

Vermeil jewelry is generally marked for the silver content. Typical marks include “STERLING” and “925.” The gold content is not usually specified, although you may come across a piece with both the silver and gold purity marks, such as “STERLING + 14K.”

Vermeil is a wonderful alternative to karat gold jewelry, as it is more affordable. Because it contains only precious metals, there are no allergy concerns and it keeps its value for years to come. Vintage gold jewelry was produced during the World War II era, but it’s more common to see Vermeil jewelry instead of plated jewelry from that period because the base metals used with plated jewelry were needed for the war effort.

Gold Filled Vintage Jewelry

Gold filled, also known as “rolled gold,” jewelry is made with a base metal (usually brass or copper) that is covered with a thick coat of gold. Unlike gold plating, the process used to create gold filled jewelry involves thick sheets of gold that are mechanically bonded using heat and high pressure, not electroplated. This bonding is permanent and the gold is much thicker than that of gold plate. It’s not uncommon to find gold filled jewelry that is fifty years old or older looking almost brand new.

In order to be considered gold filled, the gold content must be 5% or 1/20 of the total weight (1/10 if 10KT) and have a mark that identifies the karat value. Typical marks are “1/10 10KT GF,” “1/20 12KT GF,” “1/20 14KT GF,” and “1/20 18KT GF.” Sometimes you may see a mark like “14/20,” which means the outer 1/20 (5%) is 14 karat gold, the same as the “1/20 14KT GF” mark.

Most vintage gold jewelry that is gold filled is yellow in color, although you may also find pieces that are rose gold or white gold in color

Cultra Vintage Gold Filled Hearts Cultured Pearls Earrings
Vintage Gold Filled Hearts Earrings with Cultured Pearls
Vintage White Gold Filled Fluted Beads Pearls Bracelet
Vintage White Gold Filled Fluted Beads Pearls Bracelet
Vintage Gold Filled Carved Shell Cameo Brooch
Vintage Gold Filled Carved Shell Cameo Brooch

Because the layer of gold is so much thicker than plated jewelry, gold filled jewelry will not peel or flake, and with reasonable care will last as long as 14K gold jewelry. Although the gold can tarnish with age, buffing with a silver cleaning cloth or a very mild cleaning solution will usually restore the lovely finish. An added benefit is that people with sensitive skin will find it safe and comfortable to wear.

Little Known Fact: A great deal of heirloom jewelry from the 1800s was gold filled, which demonstrates that gold filled jewelry is very durable.

Karat Gold Vintage Jewelry

Karat Gold is sometimes also described as “genuine gold” or “solid gold.” Because gold is a soft metal, it is combined with other metals to make the pieces more durable. The marks stamped on gold pieces show how much of the metal is gold. The chart below explains these marks.

The karat is a very old measure of how much gold is in an alloy, or gold-blend. A measure of 1 Karat is where there is 1 part of pure gold and 23 parts of metal alloy – or 4% gold. So 24K is 100% pure gold. 9K is 37%, 14K is 58%, and 18K is 75%

Note: Some people confuse “carat” and “karat.” Carat is a unit of weight used for gemstones, such as a one-carat diamond. Karat is used to measure the amount of gold in a metal piece.

Vintage Gold Jewelry Marks
Standard Purity Marks used for Vintage Gold Jewelry

Sometimes the karat value is shown as a ratio, such as “18/24” or “14/24.” This is most commonly seen with gold filled jewelry, as mentioned in the section above.

Vintage Gold Jewelry with European Purity Marks

In Europe, purity marks are commonly shown as percentages. The most common marks are “585” for 14K gold (58.5%) and “750” for 18K gold (75%). The photos below show a 14K vintage gold jewelry Ankh cross marked with the European “585” purity mark, and an 18K vintage gold jewelry coral rose brooch marked with the European “750” purity mark.

14K Gold Stardust Finish Ankh Cross Front
14K Gold Stardust Finish Ankh Cross with European “585” Purity Mark, Front
14K Stardust Ankh Cross Back
14K Gold Stardust Finish Ankh Cross marked with European “585” Purity Mark, Back
Vintage 18K 750 Gold Swirl Coral Rose Brooch
Vintage 18 Karat Gold and Coral Rose Brooch with European “750” Purity Mark, Front
Vintage 14K 750 Gold Swirl Coral Rose Brooch
Vintage 14K Gold Swirl Coral Rose Brooch with European “750” Purity Mark, Back

Gold Colors

The three most common gold colors are yellow gold, white gold, and rose gold. Yellow gold is the traditional color used in most vintage gold jewelry. White gold gives the look of platinum and appears silver in color, and rose gold has a warm, pinkish hue. Various metals are used to produce these colors. For example, white gold usually contains gold mixed with nickel. Rose gold is usually gold combined with copper.

Tri-Color Gold

Tri-color gold is a combination of white, yellow, and rose gold and is a very desirable fashion look. This look can be similated with vermeil, silver pieces that are thickly coated with yellow and rose gold. The photos below show a Sterling Silver bracelet that has both yellow and rose gold vermeil to give the look of tri-color gold at an affordable price point.

Milor 925 Italy Wide Tri Color Cubetto Bracelet
Milor Italy 925 Wide Tri Color Sterling Silver with Yellow and Rose Gold Vermeil Cubetto Bracelet, Front
Milor Italy 925 Wide Tri Color Cubetto Bracelet
Milor Italy 925 Wide Tri Color Sterling Silver with Yellow and Rose Gold Vermeil Cubetto Bracelet, Inside

Alloys Used with Gold

An alloy is a combination of two or more metals. There are virtually hundreds of different metals that can be combined with gold. For example, nickel is mixed with gold to produce a white gold color. Those who are allergic to nickel should avoid white gold. As mentioned, copper is used with gold to produce a rose gold color. 50% gold and 50% silver can be used to create the typical yellow gold color. Small amounts of zinc (usually 2%) will also be added to make the metal hard, as both silver and gold are soft metals. Other metals that may be used are tin, palladium, and manganese. The exact metals used with gold are usually not specified in the stamp, however, the companies that produce gold jewelry will almost always know the composition of the materials they use.

Please Comment, Share, and Connect

Thanks so much for visiting the blog and I hope you now have a better understanding of vintage gold jewelry and what the various stamps represent.

I’d love to hear your feedback. Please click the comment link below this article to add your comments. Use the share buttons below to share this article. You can also use the Social Media buttons in the right sidebar to visit my pages.

Note: If you can’t find the sharing buttons, make sure you enable Javascript and/or disable your ad blocker for this site.

Thank you, Christine 🙂

Ron Gorremans

I collect military jewelry/insignia. I come across 1/20 10k markings a lot. I was informed by someone that this mark meant 1950’s or newer. Is this true?
Thanks
Ron

Buffi Buckley

1/20 means it is 1/20th gold, basically plated but call filled gold. Usually 1/20 or 1/30. In this case, the gold used is 10K

Meredith Chu

I need your help ! Vintage necklace with a small mark I can’t make out. Next to the mark is two 99 on the clasp. 999 is 24 k 9999 24k 99 ? May have come from china?

Redmama

I have a vintage gold colored pocket watch chain and the only mark on it is 2 clovers (or flowers) on the clasp. Instead of a straight bar for the button hole, it is curved. The jeweler said it was not made of gold. Can you tell me anything about this piece?

Jan Sims

I have a cameo with a gold color frame around it. On the back of the frame are these markings: 12012 KGF MARBB. Can you tell me what this means. Thanks, Jan Sims

Reesa Shaw

First, I must say that I am intrigued at all of this and am enjoying reading all of your articles! I have several pieces of my mother’s jewelry from the 60’s and 70’s, and possibly earlier. How would I go about getting them appraised and do you buy vintage jewelry?? How does this process work?? I would be happy to take photos and send them to you?? Thank you in advance for your time and consideration!
Reesa Shaw

Leanne S

I have a huge phoenix bird pin only marked 859 on the back. Any idea what this could be? I think it is gold plated.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *